Showing posts with label nate silver. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nate silver. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 04, 2009

Local Politics Ruled Elections

People have been reading too much into yesterday's elections. Today is political pundit Happy Day. Michael Steele says that it means republicans are transcendent. Ha! That's a good one. Others say voters served a message on Obama. Don't think so.
The only real loser was Sarah Palin, who inserted herself into the NY 23 race and popped out a democrat. Nate Silver says the night went to local politics:
Hoffman, indeed, had some initial success. The original Republican nominee, Dede Scozzafava, dropped out of the race after polling showed her trailing both Hoffman and Owens. But when push came to shove, Hoffman lost.
Why? Because those activists -- however well-meaning they might have been -- misunderstood the district. The 23rd is a Republican district, but it is not a particularly conservative one, having split its vote between Barack Obama and the moderate Republican John McHugh last November.
If Nancy Pelosi is regarded suspiciously in the 23rd, so are Sarah Palin and Fred Thompson, who cut commercials and robocalls on behalf of Hoffman. What the voters there wanted was a candidate who understood them. Owens -- superior to Hoffman in his command of local issues -- provided the best approximation. CNN
As for Jon Corzine, the guy was a dud:
Alternatively, consider the outcome in New Jersey, where Republican Chris Christie knocked off incumbent Gov. Jon Corzine. This election is being touted as a referendum on Obama, who took a risk -- a bad one, indeed -- by campaigning on behalf of Corzine.
But Obama was the least of Corzine's problems: Voters in Tuesday's election approved of Obama's performance 57 percent to 43 percent, according to exit polling. It was Corzine they didn't like; 27 percent of the voters who approved of Obama nevertheless found someone other than the Democratic incumbent to vote for. Read more at CNN
My contention is that the elections were a referendum on party politics. People like Obama well enough, despite all the focus on the haters, so Obama didn't have anything to do with who people voted for. Corzine and Deeds may have lost bigger without him. But people aren't going to vote for a democrat just because he or she is a democrat. If you're a politician and you're not doing your job, you're going to be ousted because Americans are getting impatient with politicians.

Friday, March 13, 2009

Behind the Approval Rating Polls

Nate Silver, numbers whiz at 538, offers some context to the polls that are now being used to slam Obama. Critics will do whatever it takes to bring him down. That's how much they love this country. 50 days? The economy isn't fixed? Well, well.
Check out Silver's analysis here. He also notes:
A well-rounded commentary on Barack Obama popularity would take note of this context. It would also disclaim, however, that Obama's first 50 days have been anything other than typical. A typical president, 50 days or so into his term, is choosing the drapes for the Lincoln Bedroom and picking out a puppy dog -- generally unobjectionable sorts of activities. Obama has chosen to put forward nearly the entirely of his agenda. One can make the case that Obama has attempted to push his agenda further in 50 days than most Presidents do in a year. Let's take that proposition somewhat literally: what do a President's approval ratings typically look like a year or so into his term?

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Warren Ruining Inauguration Parties

Warren irks me and I think he should withdraw from the inauguration until he can become more humble and educated (see his I love gays video). He threw a bone to the gay community and its supporters, getting rid of the anti-gay language from his website. That's not enough.

But people shouldn't let Rick Warren ruin their inauguration celebrations. He's one guy of many and Joseph Lowery, who contrasts with Warren, will give the benediction. Forget about Warren, for now. Continue the fight after the party. There is so much else to celebrate.
WaPo: Not that he was planning to attend, but Barack Obama should know that my sister's inauguration night party -- the one for which she was preparing Obama Punch -- has been canceled. The notice went out over the weekend, by e-mail and word of mouth, that Obama's choice of Rick Warren to give the inaugural invocation had simply ruined the party. Warren is anti-gay, and my sister, not to put too fine a point on it, is not. She's gay.

She is -- or was -- a committed Obama supporter. On the weekend before the presidential election, my sister and my mother drove from the Boston area, where they both live, to Obama's New Hampshire headquarters in Manchester. There my mother made 76 phone calls for Obama, which is not bad for someone who is 96, and gives you an idea of the level of commitment to Obama in certain precincts of my family.

I should say right off that my mother feels less strongly about Warren than my sister does. But I should add immediately that my sister feels very strongly, indeed. She's been in a relationship with another woman, the quite wonderful Nancy, for 19 years, and she resents the fact that Warren has likened same-sex marriage to incest, pederasty and polygamy.

"I'm opposed to redefinition of a 5,000-year definition of marriage," Warren told Beliefnet.com's Steve Waldman. "I'm opposed to having a brother and sister being together and calling that marriage. I'm opposed to an older guy marrying a child and calling that marriage. I'm opposed to one guy having multiple wives and calling that marriage."

Waldman asked, "Do you think those are equivalent to gays getting married?"

"Oh, I do," said Warren.

Another viewpoint from 538:
That's beside the point, though; what I think the Warren dust-up reveals is that the left is now willing to raise at least as much ruckus about the issue as the right. The left, of course, has always had its own moral compass, but it's now beginning to convert that into more focused, overtly political action. If John Kerry had won four years ago, and invited Warren or some analogous pastor to give his invocation, would there have been this much debate about it? It's hard to say for sure, but I don't think we would have heard very much about it at all. This all feels very recent, stemming from a renewed self-confidence on the part of the left, coupled in this particular instance with the aftermath of Proposition 8.

I say this as someone, by the way, who buys into the "Can't we all just get along?" side of the argument. There's a difference between feeling as though you have superior morals and feeling morally superior, and some of the discussion has veered toward the wrong side of that equation. Nevertheless, I think the passion aroused among the left on the issue has been fairly impressive, and is potentially fairly consequential.
More stories on Warren:
Will Warren be worth it?
Why Warren?
Muzzling of Warren

Wednesday, November 05, 2008

Pollsters Who Got it Right


HP: First, on the analyst tip, Nate Silver of fivethirtyeight.com was the big winner. His final projection for Barack Obama's electoral haul, at 349, stood accurate as of Wednesday morning (though North Carolina could yet add to Obama's total). On the popular vote split, Silver was also right on with his prediction of a 52.3-46.3 advantage for Obama.

As for polling firms, the respected Pew firm was right there with Silver, showing a 52-46 national vote breakdown in its final survey. (Though it's important to note that pollsters, unlike analysts, see their principal role as trying to reflect the electorate ahead of election day, as opposed to making predictions.) Rasmussen can also take a bow for getting the national numbers right.

Overall, pollster Anna Greenberg said she was impressed by the extent to which many polling firms were on the money. "I almost wish it wasn't the case, because it would have been more fun," she said. Given the controversies over "likely voter" predictions, how to weight for an expected large African American turnout, and whether cell-phone only users were under-sampled in surveys, however, Greenberg said "pollsters seem to have accurately captured the electorate."

Brent McGoldrick, a pollster who worked on the Hotline/Diageo tracking poll, agreed. "What you're really talking about with questions of the Bradley effect, or cell phones or likely voters, is the composition of electorate. And most polls just got it right. If you looked at the internals of age groups or Hispanics, you see we're even closer to rights. And that's the fundamental question." who else?