Saturday, October 17, 2009

Media's Narrative for Hillary Wrong


Something that I've been saying right here. The media likes to think we're all a bunch of simpletons and so they come up with these mind-numbing narratives.

For Hillary, it's that she's sad she's not president and that she's taken a backseat in the Obama administration.

Wrongo.

I happen to think the narratives happen because of lazy reporting. It's like the media narrative for Obama's trip to New Orleans. No one knew what they were talking about when they said the administration has made no progress there.

Though I didn't root for Hillary to be president, I sure admire her work as Secretary of State:
The sudden Clinton clamor in the media strikes the ear as especially cacophonous in light of how quiet she has been for most of her nine months in her new job. And the sound of silence out of State, in turn, has given rise to a clear conventional wisdom about Hillary’s role in Obamaville, which is part of what she was reacting to in her interviews with NBC and ABC this week. The CW, put succinctly, is that Hillary is a virtual nonentity in the administration: that in terms of political status, she ranks in the second tier, and that when it comes to policy sway, she has been out-barked and out-bitten by the pack of alpha dogs that the president has installed around her.

It’s easy enough to understand this interpretation of Clinton’s standing. After her soap-operatic campaign, the absence of drama around HRC creates cognitive dissonance for the punditocracy and other Beltway tea-leaf readers. Yet the truth is that the conventional wisdom is wrong, I think, in both its particulars and its overall verdict. And not just wrong but illustrative of a set of misapprehensions about how the woman thinks and operates—or, at least, how she’s learned to do so, especially with respect to the navigation of new terrain. Indeed, one need only look back as far as her time in the Senate to understand how she now sees and plays the game, and why, on everything from the battle over U.S. policy in Afghanistan to the shaping of her future, she’s perfectly likely to win. New York Mag